Stupid People writing reviews Misguided reviews.
Monday, July 23rd, 2007
Some lady wrote a review of the Fifth Harry Potter movie, and the people over at Gospelcom linked to it, so I read it. I had to shake my head and laugh. (here it is)
Regardless of her opinion on the entertainment value of the movie, she makes two comments that are quite revealing about her familiarity with the Harry Potter saga:
- “I think the film could have been stronger, more entertaining, and less bleak, and still remained very true to the original story.”
- “And Quidditch—what is a Harry Potter story without Quidditch?!?”
As anyone who actually read the book would know (and she implies that she has in the first comment), Harry was banned from Quidditch that year, and thus it didn’t even appear in the book. How can she comment on it’s faithfulness to the book when she obviously hasn’t even read it?!? And if she knew anything about Quidditch, she would know that it’s a quite simple game, we’ve seen enough of it, and putting it into any future Harry Potter books and/or movies would be, quite simply, boring.
Don’t try to be an expert on stuff you know nothing about.






